Yasin Ayari Scores After 11 Minutes as Brighton Win at Manchester City for the First Time, 1-0 at the Etihad, Handing City a Second Straight League Defeat
Brighton & Hove Albion had never won at Manchester City in any competition. They had tried 17 times, with five draws and 12 defeats, according to the Guardian’s match report. On Saturday, at the 18th attempt, Yasin Ayari scored after 11 minutes and Brighton held on for a 1-0 win at the Etihad Stadium.
The result left City, who started the weekend top of the Premier League, with two defeats in a row. Brighton are third on 19 points, two behind City’s 21, and the two clubs had met in a Carabao Cup shootout only four days earlier.
How the goal happened
It was not a moment of great design. The move started with a free-kick given against Elliot Anderson for a foul on Ayari, a decision the Guardian’s Jamie Jackson said “appeared” to be wrongly awarded. Lewis Dunk took it quickly and swept the ball right to Diego Gómez.
Gómez crossed low. Matheus Nunes tried to clear and missed it, the ball struck Maxim De Cuyper’s shin and bounced into the path of Ayari, who tapped in from six yards. Manchester City’s own match report described the lead as “gifted”, and Gianluigi Donnarumma was stranded.
The Premier League’s account on X showed it, crediting De Cuyper with the pass to Ayari.
De Cuyper ➡️ Ayari@BHAFC just can't stop scoring, into the lead after just 11 minutes ⚡️ pic.twitter.com/l3DUFl7Roz
— Premier League (@premierleague) October 31, 2026
Image/video: Premier League (@premierleague) on X
City had 21 shots and could not score
What followed was a long siege. City had 21 shots, six of them on target, according to Reuters figures carried by Flashscore, and none beat Bart Verbruggen. The Guardian’s Opta box says it was City’s most attempts without scoring in a Premier League home game since November 2024, when they had 23 against Tottenham. It was also the first time in 23 league games that City failed to score at home.
The chances were there. Iliman Ndiaye headed Anderson’s cross wide in the first half, and Sky Sports logged him hitting the crossbar on 52 minutes. Nico O’Reilly, a substitute, sent a header wide of an empty net on 90 minutes, which the Manchester City report called the moment a point was lost. Sky counted seven saves from Verbruggen in all, and a late one from Jérémy Doku in stoppage time.
Brighton had their own openings. De Cuyper blazed over from a low cross just after the restart, and Jack Hinshelwood, on as a substitute, missed with a lob near the end when a second goal would have settled it.
What Maresca and Hürzeler said
Enzo Maresca did not claim the result was fair. “A bit strange,” he told the BBC. “It is the same feeling as after Aston Villa away. We did enough to deserve something more, but we have to move on and try to win games.”
He kept returning to the defending. “We are conceding silly goals; we can avoid that,” he said, quoted by Sky Sports. Nunes was at fault here, as Marc Guéhi and Donnarumma were in the 2-1 loss at Aston Villa a week earlier, the BBC’s Shamoon Hafez noted. Guéhi was dropped for this game, along with Rayan Cherki, who came on for Ayyoub Bouaddi in the 55th minute.
Fabian Hürzeler’s explanation was simple. “We had to stick together and we had this feeling that defence wins today,” he said. “Defence wins you tight games. We had a defensive mindset.”
Brighton’s defensive record
That defensive mindset is backed by numbers. Brighton have won five of their last six league games and kept a clean sheet in all five wins. Their six clean sheets are the most in the Premier League this season. The club’s own report on brightonandhovealbion.com singled out Dunk and Verbruggen, and said Dunk twice threw himself in front of Erling Haaland shots.
The win had a local footnote. Ayari was one of the Brighton players who missed in the League Cup shootout on Wednesday, so his goal was a personal answer as well as a team one. You can read how that Carabao Cup shootout went on this site.
Brighton were also coming off a 5-0 win over Crystal Palace recently, a game in which Gómez scored from the halfway line. Gómez was the player who crossed for this goal.
Brighton get their first ever league win at Man City, avenging their midweek EFL Cup loss 💪
— BBC Sport (@BBCSport) October 31, 2026
Fabian Hurzeler's side are now within two points of leaders City, who lose back-to-back league game for the first time since August 2025. pic.twitter.com/q7ie3oTVS9
Image/video: BBC Sport (@BBCSport) on X
A season that keeps getting bigger
This was not Brighton’s first big result against a title rival. Sky Sports pointed out that Hürzeler’s side had also beaten Arsenal this season, and that Saturday took them to a club-record points total at this stage of a top-flight campaign. Brighton have scored 24 goals in nine league games and conceded seven, according to the table on City’s website.
Sky’s Laura Hunter was careful about the title talk. “Are they in the title race? It’s perhaps too early to tell,” she wrote, but she called Brighton a team “with superb harmony, who play with complete tactical clarity”. The Guardian’s Jackson asked who would bet against them qualifying for the Champions League. On Sky Sports News, Paul Merson went a step further: “They’ve got to be looking at Champions League football.”
The setting made it sharper. The official attendance was 60,503, and the club’s report put the travelling Brighton support at 3,044, who it said celebrated “long and loud” at the end. Before kick-off, Hürzeler and Maresca laid a wreath together as part of the remembrance commemorations, the club said.
Where City’s problems sit
The BBC’s analysis points to three areas. City have conceded 10 goals in nine league games, double the five Arsenal have let in. The midfield, rebuilt over the summer at a cost of £327m, still looks unsettled: the BBC lists £125m for Enzo Fernández, £116m for Anderson and £86m for Bouaddi, the most expensive teenager in English top-flight history.
Maresca usually starts only two of them behind a number 10, the BBC noted, but this time he started all three and left Cherki and Phil Foden on the bench. “I think it was a good idea to start with three physical midfielders,” he said, adding that he wanted fresh legs for the last 20-30 minutes.
In attack, City have scored 20 goals in nine league games, yet in their last two games they have managed only one despite creating nine big chances, per the BBC. Haaland, the BBC wrote, was starved of any real service.
The table and what is next
City stay first on goal difference, but only until Sunday. Arsenal, on 21 points from eight games, go to Anfield at 16:30 GMT (22:00 IST). The BBC said a point there is enough for Arsenal to overtake City. Our preview of that game covers the Anfield record Arsenal are chasing.
It was a rough day for the city’s other club as well. Manchester United lost 2-0 at Chelsea the same afternoon. For more match reports, see our football section.
For City, the schedule does not allow time to brood. They play RB Leipzig in the Champions League on Wednesday, with kick-off at 20:00 UK time, then travel to Nottingham Forest on Saturday for a 17:30 UK kick-off, according to the club’s report.
Sources: The Guardian, BBC Sport, Sky Sports, Manchester City, Brighton & Hove Albion.
Photo: Timmy96 / Wikimedia Commons, CC0. Emile Smith Rowe and Yasin Ayari looked on, as Jan Paul van Hecke kicked the ball during the match between Fulham and Brighton and Hove Albion.