Gerónimo Rulli Saves Two Penalties as Manchester City Beat Brighton 4-3 in a Shootout After a 2-2 Draw to Reach the Carabao Cup Quarter-Finals

Geronimo Rulli during Argentina vs Spain at the 2026 FIFA World Cup Final.

Gerónimo Rulli, Manchester City’s reserve goalkeeper, saved the last two penalties of a shootout on Wednesday night, from Yasin Ayari and Lewis Dunk, and City beat Brighton 4-3 after a 2-2 draw at the Etihad Stadium. The holders go into the Carabao Cup quarter-finals, where Bradford City of League One await.

It was not a night City controlled. Brighton led twice and had 17 shots to City’s 13, and it was Rulli, diving to his left twice in the shootout, who took City through. The BBC Sport match report lists an attendance of 49,107.

Image/video: Manchester City (@ManCity) on X

Brighton ahead twice, City level twice

Malick Yalcouyé opened the scoring after 30 minutes with a close-range finish from Georginio Rutter’s cross. There was a suspicion of offside about it. As the Sky Sports report noted, the linesman’s flag stayed down and there was no VAR in operation, so the goal stood.

City answered ten minutes later. Phil Foden set up Mateo Kovačić, who struck from the edge of the area into the bottom corner past Jason Steele. It was 1-1 at half-time.

The second half began badly for the hosts. In the 47th minute Jaouen Hadjam cut the ball back and Rutter finished first time, with Brighton in front again. Rulli then made a fingertip save to deny Rutter a second, and the BBC said the tie would not have reached penalties without it. Rutter also went round the goalkeeper and hit the side-netting.

City’s equaliser came in the 72nd minute. Rayan Cherki’s low free-kick took a deflection off Vitor Reis’s outstretched foot and wrong-footed Steele. In the Guardian‘s words: “Cherki blasted at goal, Reis stuck out a boot, Steele was wrongfooted.” It was Reis’s first goal for City, according to The Sun. Mats Wieffer then struck the post for Brighton late on, and the match went to penalties.

Nine changes, and five players given time off

Enzo Maresca made nine changes from the side beaten by Aston Villa the previous Saturday. Erling Haaland, Gianluigi Donnarumma, Rúben Dias, Elliot Anderson and Joško Gvardiol were not involved at all, after being given breaks, AFP reported. Foden and Cherki started; Marc Guéhi wore the captain’s armband.

Jérémy Doku came on for Allan in the 61st minute, according to the BBC’s line-ups. The Guardian said his arrival turned City into “a high-octane proposition”. Maresca was careful about handing out credit. “I’m not sure he changed the game, but for sure he made an impact,” he said of the Belgian.

The BBC’s match data shows how the chances fell:

  • Shots: Brighton 17, City 13
  • Shots on target: Brighton 6, City 3
  • Possession: City 56.6%, Brighton 43.4%
  • Fouls: Brighton 20, City 3
  • Woodwork hit: Brighton 2, City 0

Maresca said afterwards that he had no regrets about the rotation. “We could have done better defensively,” he said, and later: “The game was chaotic but overall we controlled it quite good.” Brighton head coach Fabian Hürzeler saw it differently. On the club’s website he said: “The moments were on their side, not on our side.”

The shootout, kick by kick

City’s own match coverage gives the order. Foden, Pascal Groß, Enzo Fernández, Matt O’Riley, Doku and Maxim De Cuyper all scored, three for each side, so it stood 3-3. Then Kovačić, who had scored in normal time, was first to miss, his penalty saved by Steele.

That handed Brighton the chance to go ahead. Ayari stepped up for their fourth kick and Rulli kept it out. Cherki scored City’s fifth, which made it 4-3, and Dunk, who had come on in the 85th minute, took the kick Brighton needed. Rulli saved that one too. The BBC said he dived full stretch to his left for both.

He had called it in advance. “Before the game I spoke to Enzo Fernández and told him if it goes to penalties I will save two,” Rulli said in an interview with City’s own channel. “I know I would save any penalty.”

Image/video: P.M. NEWS (@pmnewsnigeria) on X

The detail that stands out came afterwards. Maresca told reporters that City had not rehearsed spot-kicks at all. “To be honest, since I’ve been here we never practised penalties,” he said. “We’re very happy with the five, even Mateo. It always happens, the one that scored during the 90 minutes, and then misses the penalty.”

City scored four of their five. Brighton scored three of their five, and Hürzeler called losing a shootout “always 50-50, but of course it’s a brutal feeling.”

Who is Rulli?

Rulli is 34. The BBC says he returned to City in the summer from Marseille for £1.7m, to back up Donnarumma, and that he spent the 2016-17 season at the club without playing a first-team game. He came back to fill the place left by James Trafford, who left for Leeds for £45m.

Shootouts are not new to him. In the 2021 Europa League final he scored a penalty for Villarreal against Manchester United and then saved David de Gea’s kick to settle a marathon shootout, as the BBC recalls. If City supporters needed a second reason to like him, Wednesday supplied it.

It also reopened a question about the goalkeeper’s position. Donnarumma was at fault for Aston Villa’s second goal, and the BBC’s analysis of that defeat noted that only eight players had made more errors leading to Premier League goals than Donnarumma and Guéhi, who have three each, since the start of last season. Maresca closed the debate quickly. Asked if Rulli was putting pressure on Donnarumma, he said: “No, absolutely not from my point of view.” He added: “Rulli knows exactly his role, there is no doubt about that. Saturday it will be Gigio plus 10.” Rulli will be back on the bench for the league game, the BBC said.

The league season and the legal case

City had won their first seven league games before Nicolas Jackson’s two goals gave Villa a 2-1 win on Saturday. According to the BBC, their most recent clean sheet before that was the 3-0 win at Anfield. Maresca has lost only to Villa and Paris Saint-Germain, plus Arsenal in the Community Shield, since taking over from Pep Guardiola.

The pressure from outside the pitch is of a different kind. An independent commission found City guilty on 114 of 115 charges of breaching the Premier League’s financial rules, according to the BBC. The club lodged its appeal at 7pm on 1 October and says the ruling contains “clear material errors, of law, principle and fact”, as ESPN quoted the club’s statement.

Al Jazeera, citing AFP, reported that the chair of the Independent Football Regulator, David Kogan, said people are assuming the appeal will be heard by the middle or end of January. AFP’s match report on Wednesday added that if the appeal fails, City could face a points deduction that would effectively lead to relegation. The club has repeatedly maintained it is innocent.

Brighton again on Saturday

There is no time for either side to move on. They meet again at the Etihad in the Premier League on Saturday, kick-off 3pm GMT, which is 8.30pm in India. Brighton will stay in the Manchester area, Hürzeler said. “We have a great chance on Saturday to take revenge,” he said.

Brighton knocked Manchester United out of this competition in the previous round. In the league they lost 2-0 to Liverpool last time out, having beaten Crystal Palace 5-0 in the league game before that. Maresca expects the same approach as on Wednesday. “They always go front foot, man to man,” he said, “so they’re going to be exactly the same on Saturday.”

Etihad Stadium
Etihad Stadium. Photo: Cléria De Souza / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

The only previous League Cup meeting between the clubs was on 24 September 2008, when a Brighton side then in League One beat a City team containing Kasper Schmeichel, Vincent Kompany and Daniel Sturridge on penalties, the BBC records. The BBC lists their last three Premier League meetings as a 2-2 draw in March 2025, a 2-1 Brighton win in August 2025 and a 1-1 draw in January 2026.

Fleetwood are also in the last eight after beating Arsenal on penalties a day earlier, and our football section has the rest of this season’s match reports.

The quarter-finals are played in the week beginning 14 December. AFP says City will host Bradford City, and the Guardian’s draw lists Fleetwood against Everton or Newcastle, Crystal Palace against Sunderland and Liverpool against Bournemouth.

Sources: BBC Sport, Sky Sports, The Guardian, AFP, ESPN, Brighton & Hove Albion, Al Jazeera.

Photo: Bryan Berlin / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

SHARE:

About The Author

Passionate writer and editor sharing insights on technology, AI, and modern web development. Constantly exploring the latest trends to bring you the most accurate and engaging stories.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *