Garner, Hackney and Barry Score as Everton Beat Newcastle 3-1 in the Carabao Cup and Draw Fleetwood in the Quarter-Finals

Hayden Hackney pictured with a fan after the Millwall and Middlesbrough match.

Everton beat Newcastle United 3-1 at the Hill Dickinson Stadium on Thursday night to reach the Carabao Cup quarter-finals, with goals from James Garner, Hayden Hackney and Thierno Barry. Dan Burn pulled one back late for Newcastle, the team that won this competition in 2025. The draw that followed sends Everton to League Two Fleetwood Town, the side that knocked out Arsenal two days earlier.

A night built around who was missing

The team news arrived before the football. Everton announced that Jack Grealish, the 31-year-old England winger on loan from Manchester City, had been made unavailable for selection because of a “breach of club discipline”. The Guardian reported that he is understood to have missed training on Monday without permission, and that he returned to training afterwards. David Moyes later called it “a club decision”, the paper said.

BBC Sport’s story on the decision gave the same reason: an unauthorised absence from training. Everton were left with a small squad and a fourth-round tie against a Premier League side. The Guardian called it the biggest night in Everton’s season.

Newcastle start fast, Everton score first

Newcastle had the better of the opening 20 minutes. Harvey Barnes had a header saved by Jordan Pickford, Fabian Schär tested him from distance, and Vitalii Mykolenko made a block to stop a Jacob Ramsey shot. Matthias Jaissle’s side finished with 28 shots to Everton’s 11, and nine of those were on target, according to the BBC match page. Everton had five on target.

The goal came out of a long Pickford clearance. Amar Dedić went to retrieve it near the touchline and was closed down by Tyrique George. The ball ran to Hackney, who played it inside to Garner, and Garner put a first-time finish into the far corner in the 34th minute. It came moments after captain James Tarkowski had made a last-ditch challenge to stop Will Osula shooting from close range. ESPN, in its PA report, noted that it was Garner’s first goal since January.

“The first goal, it’s no risk, clear it,” Jaissle said afterwards, as quoted by the Guardian. “But we concede out of nothing.”

Image/video: Sky Sports Football (@SkyFootball) on X

Hackney’s first for the club

The second goal arrived on the stroke of half-time and started with a Newcastle chance. Barnes shot, Pickford gathered, and Everton were away. He threw quickly to Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, who ran at the Newcastle defence until Ramsey fouled him from behind. Referee Farai Hallam played advantage, Barry carried on and crossed from the left, and Hackney finished from close range at 45 minutes.

Newcastle had appealed for a penalty a few seconds earlier when Barnes went down under a challenge from Dewsbury-Hall. Hallam waved it away. The Guardian said the visitors “appeared to pause, waiting for the free-kick” and were punished for it.

It was Hackney’s first goal for Everton. He joined from Middlesbrough in the summer on a five-year contract for a reported £16m, and ESPN said it was only his third start for the club. BBC Sport’s readers rated him the best Everton player on the night. If you want a closer look at his career so far, his Wikipedia page covers the Middlesbrough years.

Image/video: Sky Sports Football (@SkyFootball) on X

Jaissle changed three players at the interval, bringing on Yoane Wissa, Anthony Elanga and Joelinton. According to the club’s match report, that was a record 24th appearance in the competition for Joelinton.

Barry makes it safe

Newcastle pressed for twenty minutes after the break. Wissa got a header on target and Pickford saved it. Dedić shot from range and a deflection off Hackney sent it over the bar. Pickford also stopped efforts from Lewis Hall, Elanga and Ramsey, per the Guardian.

Then Everton counter-attacked again. Garner intercepted a pass from Dedić and found Dewsbury-Hall, who took Burn out of the game and pulled the ball back for Barry. The striker had time to control it and finish in the 69th minute. BBC Sport and ESPN both count it as Barry’s seventh goal of the season; ESPN puts it at seven in 11 appearances.

Image/video: Sky Sports Football (@SkyFootball) on X

Burn headed in late on to make it 3-1. A scuffle followed involving Burn, Pickford, Tarkowski and Joelinton, and all four were booked. BBC Sport reported that Tarkowski shoved Joelinton to the ground. The sources differ on who delivered the cross and on whether the goal came in the 88th or 89th minute, so treat both as late rather than exact.

What the managers said

Jaissle did not hide behind the shot count. He told the Guardian that his team had been “naive”, and described the defeat as “shocking”. To Sky Sports he said: “We lack in the clinical approach to solve the situations; just think about the first one.” He added: “This is a learning process, but you don’t get the time. We need to learn fast, especially with these young lads. Being a young team is not an excuse any more.”

Moyes, speaking to Sky, pointed to the dressing room. “The one thing about Everton and what they’ve got is they’ve got really good values behind it,” he said. “It’s a smallish squad we’ve got, and we’re limited in some areas. But we’re doing our best to try and keep challenging.”

Newcastle have won two of their last six games in all competitions, BBC Sport noted. Before this tie they had beaten Crystal Palace 2-0 on Sunday, the club said.

The numbers from Thursday

  • Score: Everton 3, Newcastle United 1 (2-0 at half-time)
  • Scorers: Garner 34′, Hackney 45′, Barry 69′; Burn for Newcastle, 88′ or 89′ depending on the source
  • Shots: Everton 11, Newcastle 28; on target: 5 and 9
  • Possession: Everton 43.2%, Newcastle 56.8%
  • Attendance: 51,894
  • Yellow cards: Everton 5, Newcastle 3

The possession and shot figures come from the BBC’s match stats.

Fleetwood next, and Newcastle again on Monday

Everton have never won the League Cup, and BBC Sport says they have not won a major trophy since the 1995 FA Cup. Their quarter-final is away to Fleetwood, who are 18th in League Two. Fleetwood beat Arsenal 5-3 on penalties after a 1-1 draw, a result covered in our report on the Arsenal tie. Sky Sports described the draw as a chance for Everton to reach their first cup semi-final since 2016.

The rest of the last eight, per the BBC’s draw report and the Guardian: Manchester City v Bradford City, Crystal Palace v Sunderland, and Liverpool v Bournemouth. City and Liverpool both needed penalties to get here, as we covered in our reports on City against Brighton and Liverpool against Chelsea. The ties are played in the week commencing 14 December. More of our coverage sits in the football section.

The sides do not have to wait long to meet again. Newcastle host Everton in the Premier League at St James’ Park on Monday 2 November, with kick-off at 8pm GMT. Their last three meetings were a 3-1 Everton win in a friendly on 12 August, a 3-2 Everton win at St James’ Park on 28 February, and a 4-1 Newcastle win at Everton on 29 November 2025, according to the BBC’s head-to-head record.

Sources: BBC Sport, The Guardian, Sky Sports, ESPN (PA), Newcastle United.

Photo: Timmy96 / Wikimedia Commons, CC0. Hayden Hackney pictured with a fan after the Millwall and Middlesbrough match, 16 August 2025.

SHARE:

About The Author

Passionate writer and editor sharing insights on technology, AI, and modern web development. Constantly exploring the latest trends to bring you the most accurate and engaging stories.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *