Como Beat Manchester United 4-1 in the Champions League, and Bruno Fernandes Then Questioned Michael Carrick’s Tactics in Public
Como scored after 118 seconds at the Stadio Giuseppe Sinigaglia on Wednesday night and Manchester United never recovered, losing 4-1 in the Champions League league phase. The argument that followed has been louder than the match. Captain Bruno Fernandes said the coaching staff had chosen not to press man to man. Head coach Michael Carrick replied that United had “half pressed” in the second half and conceded from it. BBC Sport reports that Fernandes will keep the armband and will not be disciplined.
Two minutes, then a slide
Nico Paz curled the opener into the top corner, and Sky Sports noted that Harry Maguire gave him too much room to do it. Diogo Dalot had put a shot wide at the other end moments earlier. It was the second time in eight days that United conceded inside two minutes in Europe, after 47 seconds against Atletico Madrid, and Sky says no English side had done that in back-to-back major European games before.
The second goal came four minutes into the second half. Paz slid a pass through for Anastasios Douvikas, who ran away from Matthijs de Ligt, playing his first game in 325 days after a back problem. Paz added his own second in the 57th minute after taking the ball off Carlos Baleba in United’s half. Jacobo Ramon headed in Kaiki’s cross in the 76th minute, and Joshua Zirkzee scored for United in stoppage time from an Amad Diallo cross. The club’s own match report lists the attendance as 10,601.
By the 57th minute, as the Guardian’s Jamie Jackson wrote, Como were 3-0 up and the game was over. Carrick had changed things at the break, replacing Matheus Cunha and Andrey Santos with Diallo and Baleba, which moved Fernandes to the number 10 role. The net result was Como’s second goal. The Guardian also pointed out that United were missing nine players through injury, suspension or illness.
Full-time. pic.twitter.com/hc3LZ9oGrl
— Manchester United (@ManUtd) October 21, 2026
Image/video: Manchester United (@ManUtd) on X
- Final score: Como 4, Manchester United 1 (Paz 2′, 57′; Douvikas 49′; Ramon 76′; Zirkzee 90+1′).
- United are winless in seven games in all competitions (three draws, four defeats), their longest run since eight matches in November and December 2015.
- Como completed 594 passes, the most by any team against United in a Champions League game since Barcelona’s 725 in April 2019.
- United have three points from their first three league-phase games.
7 – Manchester United are winless in seven consecutive games in all competitions for the first time since a run of eight matches between November and December 2015.
— OptaJoe (@OptaJoe) October 21, 2026
Problems. pic.twitter.com/2CCZsu6kLX
Image/video: OptaJoe (@OptaJoe) on X
What Fernandes said, and what Carrick said back
Fernandes was taken off in the 66th minute for Zirkzee, then did 10 interviews in Como, according to BBC Sport. To TNT Sports he said: “It’s a decision from the staff to not press man to man and sometimes leave space behind and try to get the ball, wait for them, but sometimes when you give space to these teams they get confidence.” Asked whether that meant Carrick got the tactics wrong, he answered: “That’s on the manager and staff to see, not me. Sometimes you have to be more brave under pressure, take the risk of pressing high and making them uncomfortable.” Both quotes are in BBC Sport’s transcript.
He went further with Sky. “We’re not in the past, we need to look in the future,” he said, adding: “We focus too much at looking at what the club did in the past. We’re not that anymore.” Sky Sports noted that Carrick, who won every trophy possible at United as a player, represents those Ferguson years.
Carrick’s answer was blunt. “We half pressed man-to-man in the second half and ended up conceding a goal from that,” he said. “Whatever tactics you play, if you don’t run back, you ain’t going to win.” He also said: “I’m really angry.” Asked whether every player gives as much as he does, he said: “I’d like to think so. I didn’t like what I saw tonight though.” He apologised to the travelling fans afterwards; the Guardian counted about 200 of 700 still in the ground at the end.
Is the 4-2-4 the problem?
BBC Sport’s tactics correspondent Umir Irfan set out what Fernandes meant. Since Carrick took over in January, United have mostly defended in a zonal 4-2-4 or 4-4-2 that presses at chosen moments rather than everywhere. It worked last season: Bryan Mbeumo scored United’s equaliser in a 3-2 win at Arsenal in January from a well-timed press, not a man-to-man one.
This season, Irfan wrote, opponents have found ways around it. Milan, managed by former United head coach Ruben Amorim, used a back five to outnumber the front four. Atletico used a back four with split centre-backs, which dragged Dalot and Youri Tielemans across big distances to reach Alejandro Grimaldo. Lisandro Martinez said after that Atletico game: “You can’t stay with what you did last season.” Irfan’s reading is that Fernandes may be asking for a change of that kind, and Carrick’s reply is that no system works without running.
A second public argument in eight days
Eight days earlier Martinez had criticised director of football Jason Wilcox and the club’s summer recruitment after the 2-0 defeat in Madrid; he later apologised. BBC Sport adds that a Ten Hag interview with The Athletic, about “broken promises” and a “toxic culture”, landed in between, and that the club has won two of 11 games this season with one clean sheet.
The same BBC report says United have begun identifying possible replacements even as Carrick is expected to take charge on Sunday. It names Eddie Howe, Antonio Conte and Julian Nagelsmann as interested, and says Unai Emery and Fabian Hurzeler are rated highly but would be hard to extract from their clubs. It also records a counter-view inside Old Trafford that constant managerial change has not stopped the decline and that players are under-performing.
Manchester United have conceded 4+ goals and lost in the Champions League for the fourth time in their history:
— Squawka (@Squawka) October 21, 2026
◎ Barcelona 4-0 Man U (1994)
◎ Bayern 4-3 Man U (2023)
◎ FC Copenhagen 4-3 Man U (2023)
◉ Como 4-1 Man U (2026)
Eek. 😬 pic.twitter.com/ozYvjOC6tF
Image/video: Squawka (@Squawka) on X
How Como did it
Cesc Fabregas had a side that attacked and defended as a unit, in the Guardian’s account. Da Cunha, Baturina and Paz combined for the second goal; Kaiki, a substitute, supplied the fourth. The Guardian put the experience gap at 62 total Champions League appearances for Como’s players against 242 for United’s.
The Guardian called it “the most famous victory of their 119 years”. According to Wikipedia, the club was declared bankrupt in 2004 and again in 2016, and re-entered Serie D in 2017. It returned to Serie A in 2024 after 21 years away and finished fourth in 2025-26 to earn this Champions League debut. Their next game is at home to Sassuolo on Saturday 24 October, per the club.
The verdicts on Fernandes
Few pundits defended the timing. BBC Sport gathered the reaction. Jamie Carragher, on CBS Sports, called it an “awful attitude and not what a Manchester United captain should be.” Kasper Schmeichel told BBC Radio 5 Live that Fernandes “probably should not be saying these things because it’s only going to add to the problems.” Andy Mitten, editor of United We Stand, said the captain had “thrown his coach under the bus”, while noting that fans are divided.
Wayne Rooney, a close friend of Carrick, said he was in “shock” and “disbelief” and “as worried as I’ve been for a long time”. Of the players he said: “These players, they’re selfish.” BBC Sport also reports that Fernandes’s form has dipped sharply from last season, when he was named PFA and FWA Player of the Year and broke the Premier League record for assists in a single season.
Inside the club, the BBC reports, there is some sympathy for Fernandes given how the game went, alongside disappointment at what he said.
What happens before Sunday
Carrick holds his news conference at Carrington at 13:30 BST on Friday, which is 6 pm in India. He is expected to be asked about Fernandes, whose place against Bournemouth at Old Trafford on Sunday 25 October is not confirmed. Bournemouth arrive after beating Milan 3-0 in the Europa League on Thursday, BBC Sport reports, and after their first Premier League win under Marco Rose last week.
That BBC piece also notes that Premier League clubs have lost four of 26 games in the three European competitions this season, and United are responsible for two. Elsewhere the week has been kinder: Arsenal drew 2-2 at Bayern Munich and Liverpool came from 2-0 down to beat Villarreal 4-3, and we previewed PSG v Barcelona. More in our football coverage.
Sources: BBC Sport, Sky Sports, The Guardian, Como 1907, Wikipedia.
Photo: Timmy96 / Wikimedia Commons, CC0