Liverpool Beat Chelsea 6-5 on Penalties After a 1-1 Draw to Reach the Carabao Cup Quarter-Finals as Wesley Fofana Misses the Decisive Penalty
Liverpool beat Chelsea 6-5 on penalties at Anfield on Wednesday night after a 1-1 draw, and Wesley Fofana’s miss with the 16th kick of the shootout sent them into the Carabao Cup quarter-finals. Both goals in normal time were penalties as well: Morgan Rogers scored for Chelsea in the 40th minute and Cody Gakpo answered in the 43rd. Liverpool now host Bournemouth, Andoni Iraola’s former club, in the week commencing 14 December.
- Result: Liverpool 1-1 Chelsea, Liverpool win 6-5 on penalties (fourth round, Anfield, 28 October 2026)
- Goals: Rogers (Chelsea, 40th minute, penalty); Gakpo (Liverpool, 43rd minute, penalty)
- Shootout: Liverpool scored 6 of 8, Chelsea 5 of 8; Fofana’s miss was the 16th kick
- Attendance: 60,214; referee Darren England
- Next: Liverpool v Bournemouth in the quarter-finals, week commencing 14 December
Two penalties in three minutes
For the first 40 minutes there was little to report. Neither goalkeeper had been tested by the half-hour mark, according to Liverpool’s own match report, and the game was played mostly in midfield. Then it flipped twice in a short spell.
In the 40th minute Ryan Gravenberch clipped Moisés Caicedo inside the Liverpool area and the referee, Darren England, pointed to the spot. Jordan Henderson, the former Liverpool captain, picked up the ball to a chorus of boos and handed it to Rogers, who sent Giorgi Mamardashvili the wrong way, as BBC Sport described it. Three minutes later Fofana handled the ball at a corner and Gakpo sent Mike Penders the wrong way from the spot.
Both calls were made quickly. The Guardian’s Andy Hunter wrote that England called both penalties “instantly and correctly”, and that the game benefited from having no video assistant referee. Sky Sports called both penalties “needlessly conceded”. ESPN’s PA report said the fact that two needlessly conceded penalties brought the only goals “spoke volumes” about the game itself.
The goalkeepers kept it level
The second half was short on goals and long on saves. Mamardashvili, Liverpool’s deputy to Alisson, pushed away a Rogers effort early on and later denied Chelsea substitute Marco Palestra with a one-handed stop. At the other end Penders, who had made an error in Chelsea’s 2-0 home league loss to Tottenham on Saturday, saved a close-range header from Ronald Araújo and kept out a low shot from Bradley Barcola, according to the Guardian.
Late on, two Chelsea blocks stopped certain goals. The club’s own report credits Levi Colwill and then Josh Acheampong with “a sensational pair of blocks” when it looked certain Florian Wirtz or Gakpo would score from point-blank range. The numbers back up how even it was. BBC Sport’s match stats show 10 shots for Liverpool and 11 for Chelsea, four on target each, and possession of 51.7% to 48.3%.
Iraola made seven changes from the side that beat Brighton on Sunday, and four young players started: Trey Nyoni, Rio Ngumoha, James McConnell and Lewis Koumas, per Sky Sports. Liverpool’s own account named its Player of the Match afterwards.
Well in, Trey 👏
— Liverpool FC (@LFC) October 28, 2026
Our Player of the Match 🆚 Chelsea! pic.twitter.com/zDm1h9XFGp
Image/video: Liverpool FC (@LFC) on X
Iraola was pleased with the young starters. “I think he has done very well. Really well,” he said of Nyoni, adding that it is good for young players to “live these experiences in cup competitions, where if you lose you are out”, in his post-match press conference.
Sixteen penalties, five that failed
With no extra time in this round, it went straight to penalties. Chelsea’s account of the shootout, kick by kick, is the cleanest record of what happened, and it runs like this:
- Alexis Mac Allister scored for Liverpool (1-0); Pedro Neto scored for Chelsea (1-1)
- Alexander Isak scored (2-1); Rogers scored (2-2)
- Gakpo scored (3-2); Romeo Lavia scored (3-3)
- Wirtz scored (4-3); Valentín Barco hit the inside of the post and missed (4-3)
- Kostas Tsimikas, with the chance to win it, sent his kick well over the bar (4-3)
- Henderson scored (4-4); Barcola scored (5-4); Colwill scored (5-5)
- Penders saved from Gravenberch (5-5); Mamardashvili saved from Emmanuel Emegha, on his Chelsea debut (5-5)
- Joe Gomez scored (6-5); Fofana sent his kick over the bar and Liverpool had won
Five kicks failed in all: Barco, Tsimikas, Gravenberch, Emegha and Fofana. Tsimikas matters to the story because the Guardian noted that he played a match-winning role at Wembley four years ago and missed the chance to repeat it. Emegha’s miss in sudden death had been a chance for Chelsea to win it, as the club’s own report points out.
Gomez’s kick and Mamardashvili’s notes
The most unusual kick came from Joe Gomez. ESPN’s PA report says he has not scored in 280 appearances for Liverpool, and BBC Sport adds that he has never scored in a competitive game for Liverpool, England or his former club Charlton. A shootout penalty does not count as a goal on his official record, but he hit it into the top corner anyway. Afterwards he told ITV: “It was nice that it went in,” and praised the goalkeeper: “Giorgi is a great ‘keeper,” as quoted on Liverpool’s website.
Mamardashvili’s save from Emegha gave Gomez the chance. Iraola said he had told the goalkeeper before the shootout: “We need to save two.” Mamardashvili replied, by Iraola’s account: “We have to allow somebody to miss a penalty.” He saved one, Penders saved one, and three kicks missed. The goalkeeper then told ITV, as ESPN reported, that the research notes he carried were no use: “I had this paper as well, but everything was wrong!” Asked whether the notes helped him at all, he said: “No.” On the Emegha kick he said he watched the taker’s standing leg and chose to dive to his right.
BBC Sport users agreed with the verdict. Their average ratings put Mamardashvili top of the Liverpool players at 7.83, ahead of Araújo on 7.80.
Job done. Into the next round 👊 pic.twitter.com/X57jKOBVUn
— Liverpool FC (@LFC) October 28, 2026
Image/video: Liverpool FC (@LFC) on X
Chelsea’s long record from the spot against Liverpool
Chelsea arrived with a record that nobody at the club could have enjoyed reading. The Guardian said they had faced Liverpool on penalties four times before and lost all four: the 2007 Champions League semi-final, the 2019 Uefa Super Cup, and the FA Cup and League Cup finals of 2022. BBC Sport counted this as Liverpool’s fifth straight shootout win over Chelsea. ESPN’s PA report recalled a final at Wembley four years ago, which Liverpool won 11-10 in a shootout where only one player missed. This one was nowhere near as clean.
Rogers, who scored in normal time and again in the shootout, was blunt afterwards. “It is probably the worst way to lose a game,” he told ITV, as BBC Sport reported. “It was an even game and at times we had the better of it.”
Alonso’s selection and Chelsea’s week
It was Xabi Alonso’s third defeat in three visits to Anfield as a manager, following losses with Bayer Leverkusen in 2024 and Real Madrid in 2025, according to Al Jazeera’s AFP report. Alonso, who won the Champions League as a Liverpool player in 2005, kept his reaction measured. “Every time you reach the penalties, someone will feel it is harsh to go out of the competition,” he said. On priorities he was direct: “This is the least important competition for us and now the focus is on the Premier League.”
The selection drew questions anyway. Chelsea were without the suspended Cole Palmer and the injured João Pedro, started Danny Welbeck in attack and Henderson in an advanced midfield role, and left Estêvão on the bench for the full night. The Guardian called that decision “mystifying”. On BBC Radio 5 Live, former Crystal Palace striker Clinton Morrison said he did not know how Estêvão had not got on the pitch. Chelsea also lost defender Maxence Lacroix before half-time with an apparent hamstring injury, and Colwill replaced him.
The turnaround is short. Chelsea host Manchester United in the Premier League at 12.30pm UK time on Saturday 31 October, a fixture the club’s report flagged as the next job.
Where this leaves Liverpool and the rest of the last eight
For Liverpool this was a fifth win in a row in all competitions, according to Sky Sports, and the third in a row at home. Iraola said before this run that Liverpool were “struggling a little bit at home”. He now has a quarter-final against a club that knows him well. Speaking before the draw, he said: “The only team I don’t want is Bournemouth.” Bournemouth beat Aston Villa 3-0 in the same round on Wednesday, and three days earlier they had won 3-0 at Old Trafford.
Elsewhere in the last eight, Manchester City also went through on penalties against Brighton and will face Bradford City. Fleetwood Town knocked out Arsenal from the fourth tier the night before and now play Everton or Newcastle United, the tie played on Thursday. Crystal Palace meet Sunderland. All four ties are in the week commencing 14 December, per the draw published by Sky Sports and the Guardian.
BBC Sport pointed out that Jürgen Klopp and Arne Slot both reached the League Cup final in their first seasons in charge, and that Iraola will have that in the back of his mind. For more on the football season so far, see our football section.
Before any of that, Liverpool face Arsenal at Anfield on Sunday, which Iraola called “the biggest one” in his Sky Sports interview. BBC Sport worked out that a win over the defending champions would leave Liverpool three points behind them in the Premier League table.
Sources: The Guardian, BBC Sport, Liverpool FC, Chelsea FC, Sky Sports, ESPN (PA), Al Jazeera (AFP).
Featured image: Giorgi Mamardashvili arriving at Craven Cottage prior to the match between Fulham and Liverpool, 4 January 2026. Photo: Timmy96 / Wikimedia Commons, CC0.